Friday, July 23, 2010

If Options have impacted CA final results, we will reconsider ....says ICAI President!

Ever since the CA final results were declared on July 19th, there has been an outburst of emotions ( mostly anger ) in our profession..the members and students being most vocal in expressing their shock and dismay at the barely 3% passing result in CA final exams. Many brilliant students have not been able to make it and in may CA firms, where more than a dozen articles had appeared for CA final, not even a single student could make it!!!!!!!!!!!!
And so, when i got a chance to interview our ICAI President Mr Amarjit Chopra on the evening of July 20th ( which will be telecast on Bloomberg UTV today ) , i could not resist asking a question on the CA exam results and what had gone wrong? .......And i must appreciate that the ICAI President gave a comprehensive, straight and blunt answer ...here is what he said about the poor CA final results:
Question; On whether ICAI did some quality control ( or marks cutting )?
Amarjit Chopra:
" Not even a single student, who was passing, has failed...only the students who were failing, have failed....."

Question: Did removal of options play a part in poor results?
Amarjit Chopra:
" If it is due to removal of options, it does raise an issue and we will deliberate it in examination committee......If Options have impacted performane, we will have a look at it . "

Question: On whether students were not upto the mark in their preparations?
Amarjit Chopra:
" If the students have not performed, they have not performed! I have been a Teacher and the Teacher in me will not die. It is important for me that many students do qualify..No hardship is bigger than the hardship of failure. "

Questions: More practical training based questions a cause?
Amarjit Chopra:
" More practical training based questions are being asked and that may also be a reason .. ( for the poor results ) . But that we are not going to change. "

On coaching classes:
Amarjit Chopra:
" Students must introspect on what sort of coaching they are receiving....over reliance on coaching classes is proving to be fatal. "

No comments:

Post a Comment